Showing posts with label Greg Daniels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Greg Daniels. Show all posts

Thursday, April 30, 2026

Top 12 in TV of 2025

Announcement: I will be winding down on this blog. To anyone who read for the past 20 years, thank you. I will be migrating my content almost exclusively to my Patreon, and potentially to Substack. 

Even if I never get any readers, this would be the one thing I do a year for myself. Read, enjoy, fight, and debate me on this!

1. Resident Alien (Syfy) – Long one of my favorite series on the airwaves, Resident Alien reimagines the Andy Griffith show in the remote mountains of Colorado with a socially out-of-step alien and a surprisingly deep mythology. At times, this mythology could feel overcomplicated for light viewing, but it was remarkable how well things tied together in the last batch of episodes. On top of that, the catharsis of each "yes, he's an alien" reveal gave me such a strong sense of feels, I can't help but let emotion guide my judgment in placing this as the best show of the year. The conclusion validated the show's great run over so many years.

2. Your Friends and Neighbors (Apple) -- It’s the standard plot from the golden age of TV with The Americans, Breaking Bad and Ozark — ordinary guy’s story arc veers towards illegality, he’s in too deep, and has no choice but to find his way from the hole he’s dug. At  least that’s how one expects it will turn out, but the show does some pretty epic zagging as the main character –  a bitter divorced dad (Jon Hamm) – doubles down on his lies through the finish line This is a rare show from this genre that employs a reverse dramatic irony: The audience is rarely let in on how far ahead of the game Coop is. On top of this, the show folds in a convincing family drama and a meaty satire of suburban mores.

3. The White Lotus (HBO) – I can pick at a few minor glitches in the season: The first three episodes were too slow of a burn for an eight-episode season; a few minor character tics didn't quite land; the power lady trio never got hooky enough; Scott Glenn character's actions made no sense; Sam Rockwell felt too much like a stunt cameo; and the White Lotus Parker Posey was more over-the-top than even Christopher Guest Parker Posey. OK, I can pick quite a few. Still, this is generally the best thing on TV and has so much ambition and craftsmanship at every step. The stories resonate with me over a year later. And, my god. the opening credits. That is some unsettling music.

4, The Studio (HBO) - Few shows have infused the Hollywood-mocks-itself format with such zippy energy. The show operates under a standard Murphy’s Law cynicism, but true to the Hollywood spirit, the crew at Continental Studios always knows another opportunity is around the corner. The dialogue rests somewhere between Tina Fey and Aaron Sorkin’s less preachier projects and the cast gels like few others. Seth Rogen, Ike Barinholtz, the deeply missed Catherine O’Hara, the never-failing Kathryn Hahn, are joined by newcomer Chase Sui Wonders and several of Hollywood’s most improbable cameos.

5. The Paper (Peacock)-Considering The Office has been our de facto comfort viewing for nearly 20 years, it would be impossible for Greg Daniels' follow-up The Paper live up to the hype, but let’s take off our rose-colored glasses and remember how much of an egotistical oaf Michael Scott was in the first few episodes. So yes, I do declare this is off to a better start with characters with delightful idiosyncrasies we’re just beginning to peel the layers off of. The inane boss activity (particularly Sabrine Impacciatore) occurring at the level above our lead protagonist, freeing Domnhall Gleeson’s idealistic Ned to be a sweetheart that’s worth rooting for.

6. Poker Face (Peacock)-Leans on the same three tropes every episode -- accidental murderer, detective in the right place at the right time, and deus-ex-machina to get the hero kicked out of her home every -- BUT Riann Johnson imbues every episode with movie-level quality. That's a pretty high level of consistency for a show that switches settings every episode. It also helps that Natasha Lyonne is so charismatic in whatever she's in.

7. The Four Seasons (Amazon)-Unfairly compared to the original film by the critical sphere. Steve Carell, restless from his marriage (to Kerri Kinney), experiences a mid-life crisis and subsequent May-December romance that threatens to throw off the long-standing equilibrium of the friendship between three couples. The show's format of rotating over four vacations is clever. The show is largely populated with comedic actors, but it's oh so sweet, and the automatic reaction by the gang to the May-December romance is surprisingly salient.

8. Stick (Apple)-Owen Wilson has played sleazebags (Wedding Crashers, Starsky and Hutch), wide-eyed nomads (Midnight in Paris, Darjeerling Limited, Royal Tenenbaums) and the occasional sweet spot in between (You Me and Dupree, Internship), but this role as a hustling ex-golfer looking to make a sincere turn on a young talent feels like the culmination of the Owen Wilson persona. With the golfer (Peter Dager) and his mother (Mariana Trevino); a she/they caddy who’s not shy about her zoomer political views (Lilli Kay); and an old friend (Marc Maron), the quintet hits the road on a qualifying tour. The show unapologetically delves into generational gaps with at least one character (Marc Maron) who’s on the wrong side of political correctness, but it navigates some edgy material to pull off the found family trope. It’s even goshdarn heartwarming  without losing its edge:  Each character has at least one solid foil among the other members of the quintet.

9. Spud Hut (Smosh) - An entirely improvised series that premie on Smosh's YouTube channel with the main cast often doubling on key roles. The basic premise is a Romeo and Juliet story between two employees at opposing baked potato vendors in a mall. Improv is generally inconsistent and can sometimes overly rely on the gimmick, but these guys have a great knack for "yes and"-ing the right spots and building from there. Good improv has a contagious glee from the actors discovering in real time that they hit the right notes. Plus, the costumes are adorable. 

10. Running Point (Netflix) – Inspired by the Buss family of the Los Angeles Lakers dynasty, the sports sitcom takes a fish-out-of-water angle at the NBA with a female executive at the helm of the fictional LA Waves franchise. It’s exec-produced by sitcom pros Ike Barinholtz and Mindy Kaling so there’s a familiar pace linking to when the single camera sitcom was finding its stride in the 2010s. The sitcom has inspired casting—Kate Hudson, Drew Tarver, Justin Theroux, and Scott MacArthur—as siblings who inherit a basketball team. It moves fast, cleverly segments certain episodes to tangential stand-alone shots, and features a great array of guest stars.

11. Nobody Wants This (Netflix)-The second season premiere launched the characters with a glaring lack of consistency. Whereas hunky (that adjective appears mandatory, based on the show's treatment of the character) Rabbi Noah had previously delcared that he'd throw his calling away from love, the second season begins with Noah never officially quitting. He and Joanna oscillate heavy between love and faith throughout much of the season. However, everyone in Noah and Joanna's orbit gets a little more colored in that there's hardly a character I wouldn't want to hang out with. Throw in exciting new bears and characters (Morgan's shady ex-shrink/boyfriend; Noah's new uber-lax Rabbi boss), and it still makes my list despite that retcon glitch.

12. Grosse Pointe Garden Society (NBC) – It's a show about gardening and murder but not really either of those things. Even with a flat murder twist, the show delivers a compelling take on an adrift version of adulthood, and the intersecting plots are doubly rich. Two actors that have been begging for meatier work --Melissa Fumero and Josh Radnor -- turn in career-highs here.

Honorable Mention: Deli Boys (Hulu), DMV (CBS/Paramount Plus), English Teacher (FX), Friend Zoned (Fubi), Ghosts (CBS), Going Dutch (Fox), Haunted Mansion (Netflix), Krapopolis (Fox), Man on the Inside (Netflix), Rain Maker (Peacock)

For Reference, Everything Else I Saw This Year:
America's #1 Family (Amazon), Bat-Fam (Amazon), Dark Winds (AMC), Cassandra (AMC), Cobra Kai (YouTube Red ---> Netflix), Chad Powers (Hulu), Black Rabbit (Netflix), Destination X (Peacock), Etoile (Amazon), Futurama (Fox ---> Comedy Central ---> Hulu), Good Cop/Bad Cop (The CW), Hunting Wives (Netflix), Long Story Short (Netflix), It's Always Sunny (FX), Krapopolis (Fox), Last Resort (Apple) North of North (Netflix), Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy (Amazon), Shrinking (Apple), SNL (NBC), Studio C (BYU TV) , Stumble (Peacock/NBC), Twisted Metal (Peacock), Universal Basic Guys (Fox), Upload (Amazon) Yes, Chef (Peacock)

Tuesday, April 27, 2021

The baffling failure of Rutherford Falls




Once upon a time, Greg Daniels and his writer Mike Schur set out to adapt a show around a stubborn protagonist who lived in his own reality. That was Michael Scott and within six episodes, he was retooled into a more self-aware character. The show instantly became better when the character at its center was more empathic and relatable.

 

So why do they keep repeating the same mistake. Leslie Knope was nauseating in the first season of Parks and Recreation before they righted the shop and General Mark Naird suffers from much the same problem in the inaugural season of Space Force. Apparently, they haven’t learned their lesson with the character of Nathan Rutherford.  Played be Ed Helms, he’s a proprietor of a historical museum, a mayor (the kind that has no actual power), and descendant of a town’s first settler who is obsessed with his place in history. 

He’s seen as a harmless rube until a proposal comes up to move a statue of Rutherford’s namesake and town founder from a traffic circle where it is causing traffic accidents. When Nathan attempts to defend his position, he puts his foot in his mouth and shows an entitlement and privilege large enough to get him cancelled on an epic scale. Before one thing leads to another, Rutherford invokes the wrath of the local Native American tribe and gets his family embroiled in a law suit that tears through the town.

 

In an age where the country is sharply divided over the issue of whether any statues of white people should stand at all barring a demanding purity test, this seems like extremely risky territory to wade in to. It helps that the wide spectrum of attitudes of a statue (“I think they should make a statue about my grandmother instead”, “statues are boring”, “it’s a traffic hazard” etc.) beyond the typical “statues as symbols of hatred” are on display. But it’s an odd next project for as progressive a show runner as Michael Schur (who does enlist a Native American show-runner to be fair). I haven’t read any critics’ reviews but I watched the first episode thinking of all the ways that self-righteous bunch would be waiting to anoint this show with the Scarlett P (for “problematic”), even if the philosophy of the show hews more towards their values.

 
The show initially seems determined to make a strawman out of Rutherford—he’s exceedingly stubborn and so utterly resistant to change – that he’s basically what you’d get if Andy Bernard got educated by the Daughters of the Confederacy instead of Cornell. At the same time, the show is concurrently woke in almost every aspect outside of Nathan’s blindspot for protecting his heritage.  Nathan’s best friend is a Native American history obsessive and the two bond over shared history and he displays the appropriate sensitivity to microaggressions and intersectionality. When the two want to disqualify a white history fair candidate because he’s caught on tape using a patois, it’s the kind of societal overcorrection I wouldn’t be behind in real life but it might hit the social justice sweet spot for these viewers.

Similarly, Nathan’s intern/assistant/lackey is a Southeast Asian gay teen who he has a relationship based on mutual respect to the degree that doing drudge work for school credit isn’t considered exploitation for a high schooler of any race.

The problem again, is just the sheer oblivious of Nathan and the lack of character development until, perhaps, the last two episodes of the season.

This series dramatizes several issues like the value and profitability of nostalgia, how different oppressed peoples work together in the present, whether casinos are helpful or hurtful to Native tribes, if grievance is enough currency alone to accomplish objectives and more. These issues can spur thought-provoking conversations only if they involve characters that can be taken seriously.

The show has the potential to be better in the second season as things stand, but why take so long to set such elementary things into motion?

 




Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Now writing at TV Fanatic!

I wrote for TV Fanatic for a while in 2014 and 2015 but it didn't work out. I'm thrilled that I've recently been given a second chance to contribute editorials to the website and that's where a lot of my work has been going to leaving me less time to update this blog.



I wrote this essay about the TV show Ramy and how I felt like *spoiler alert* it dropped the ball at the end of a near-perfect season. The essay touches on how shows with comedians are a dime a dozen and it's hard to break away from that. It also touches on how shows (BoJack Horseman and Orange is the New Black as well) are reveling lately in male characters coping with past sins without much of a path forward or sense in-universe:

https://www.tvfanatic.com/2020/07/ramy-season-2-boasts-a-uniquely-introspective-character-despite/

This essay is about how shows maintain a distance from the current political climate even when they have something political to say. Why do they maintain such distance and how do they affect viewers if they're avoiding the issues? I touch a lot on Space Force and The Good Place here.

https://www.tvfanatic.com/2020/07/space-force-the-good-place-and-the-art-of-making-the-political-a/

This is essay came about because I was watching the Parks and Recreation reunion and remembering that the show in its later stages is just unwatchable to me. I found it too saccharine and artificially happy. So I posed the question: What if it stayed truer to its original tone? True, the first season was awkward but it had some good things going for it.

https://www.tvfanatic.com/2020/07/what-if-parks-and-recreation-had-stayed-closer-to-its-original-t/



Do the recent blackface and voice over controversies mean we should restrict art? I have written a lot of essays critical of the identity politics movement and wokeness and as that school of thought has accelerated beyond repair in the past two months, I felt the need to add my voice once more.

https://www.tvfanatic.com/2020/07/do-the-recent-blackface-and-voiceover-controversies-mean-we-shou/