Top 12 Shows of 2020

(click here for past editions)

1. The Great (Hulu) -Fans of the 2018 film “The Favourite” will appreciate the way writer Tony McNamara portrays idle pleasures and high drama as two sides of the same coin—ultimately a game that the nobility must play to curry favor with those more powerful than them. As in “The Favourite” the hierarchy leads upward to a monarch (Nicholas Hoult) with absolute power. That’s where the show presents a stark contrast between the villain and heroine (Elle Fanning) Catherine the Great who history tells us will come to modernize Russia with her rule. The question is when and finding the answer has been quite a ride so far. 

2. Dead to Me (Netflix)-Newly widowed Jen Hardy (Christina Applegate) attends a grief group where she makes the acquaintance of a strangely eager Judy (Linda Cardinelli). Judy chips away at Jen’s veneer until she forms a makeshift friendship. Or at least that’s how it seems. Within the first few episodes of the inaugural season of “Dead To Me”, it’s revealed that Judy isn’t a fellow griever but someone involved in the death of Judy’s husband and that her guilt is driving her to make it up in some karmic fashion. It’s a premise Hitchcock or Fincher would have killed for, playing out in a slow burning series. The second season expands the scale of twists--the introduction of an identical twin to the deceased is deliciously soapish (a cheap excuse to keep James Marsden employed)--but more importantly, it heightens the emotional stakes.  

 

3. Brockmire (IFC) -A lot of TV in the #metoo era is about men getting consumed by dark pasts and no one seemed more hopeless than the superhumanly aloof baseball broadcaster Jim Brockmire in the first season, but his redemptive arc that gelled in the final season makes such a light out of the tunnel not only seem possible but easy-peasy. That’s really an “It’s a Wonderful Life” scale miracle worth celebrating. In the final season, the show leapt over a decade into the future in the midst of a technocratic dystopia. Our loose-lipped hero is charged not just with personal rehabilitation but saving baseball as we know it. Pretty ambitious for a show that, remember, originated out of a “Funny or Die” sketch.

 

4. Ramy (Hulu)- The titular Ramy (Ramy Yousef) is a Muslim-American who walks the walk, but with his backwards cap and scruffy beard, he might be too far out of place on a season of Jersey Shore. Or at least, that’s the Ramy at the start of season 1. In the show’s second season, Ramy seeks a spiritual mentor (Mahershala Ali) in Sheik Malik and the show’s central relationship maintains an air of enigma. Malik projects nothing but warmth but never gives Ramy easy answers. Whereas most shows about single guys are about wanting to get laid, this is a show about a guy who wants to veer away from sexual temptation to attain spiritual enlightenment. How refreshing is that? The show also has a penchant for experimentation along the lines of “Louie” or “Master of None” (though way better) as it shifts the spotlight around.

5. What We Do in the Shadows (FX) - One of my serendipitous discoveries last year, this adaptation of New Zealand legends Jermaine Clement and Taiki Wahiti shows no signs of losing its edge. With Laszlo assuming the alternate persona of Jackie Daytona just to escape a fight, Colin Robinson becoming omnipotent through an office promotion, and Nadja gaslighting an octogenarian just to get back a necklace, this is one of the most consistently brilliantly plotted out TV shows on a per episode basis. As a quartet of vampires who have lived hundreds of years longer than the average human, they’ve largely been set in their ways like your creaky grandmother who can’t understand e-mail. Which is why the contrasts with Colin Robinson holding an office job work so well on a humor level or why Guillermo’s character development works so well in pathos.

6. The Boys (Amazon) –“The Boys” reached a new level of gripping as the evil guys became eviler, the good guys got their shit together, and everyone in the middle was forced to make a choice. Not only is this show not some hyper-merchandised part of the MCU, it’s technically not a super hero show. In this universe, super heroes are really a façade controlled by an evil company (although an evil façade is probably an accurate description of Marvel Studios, I’m guessing) in which children buy and inject a chemical. The show is allegorical to all a plethora of wrongs stemming from celebrity culture. In the second season, however, the show took on a darker tone which came with its own set of ups and downs but it was never easy to peel your eyes away. “The Boys” also deserves credit in its second season for pushing Hughie to the side and becoming a true ensemble show. 

 

7. Upload (Amazon)-Greg Daniels’ meditation on a class-based afterlife in which only those who pay can get their minds transferred to a lakeside resort after their body gives up on them, is sure to be classified as a comedy based on the pedigree of the creator (Daniels is most famous for “The Office”). But this is inaccurate. I rarely laughed and there’s nothing wrong with that. “Upload” is a thoughtful sci-fi piece that poses harder questions in a light-hearted way about our ideal reality and class. The show also has parallel mystery and romance story lines that pace along well under the main arc.

8. The Circle (Netflix)-Before the virus caused such massive shifts to our world, the American version of this show was already among the buzziest on television. The central gimmick-- isolated strangers tasked with growing bonds over social media and sussing out each other’s authenticity — surreptitiously became one of the most prescient mirrors of our era is we were forced to quarantine in pretty much the same way. But while the contestants were quarantined, that didn’t get them down. They danced for no one but themselves (in one of the most bizarre and best sequences of the show), kept themselves happy and busy, made incredible friendships, and occasionally fell for one another. Through four different countries, the show endured as a fascinating social experiment, because it reflected how online spaces allow us the freedom to present ourselves in a society with challenges therein. 

9. AP Bio (Peacock)-From outré comedy writer Mike Patrick O’Brien (responsible for some of SNL’s weirder sketches of the decade), “A.P. Bio” was miraculously rescued from cancellation-land in its third season by NBC’s spin-off paywall network. The show’s anti-hero, Jack Griffin, started out as a take on the bad teacher trope, ratcheted up to absurdium: He wasn’t just apathetic about not teaching biology, he actively avoided it to the point of logistical inefficiency. After a few episodes the show found a strange groove and morphed into an anti-sitcom sitcom in which Jack does indeed bond with his students (partially through guilt) while retaining his bitter apathetic ways. The ending of the second season promised an escalation as Helen DeMarco (Paula Pell) was enrolled in Jack’s class which meant an end to his charade. Unfortunately, the show reneged on this direction in the first episode which meant more predictable shenanigans. Fortunately, the show’s shenanigans are still sublime with one of the best ensembles on TV.

10. Fargo (FX)-Told in exquisite visual detail, this crime saga of two competing factions -- the Italians and African-American mob families in the 1950s— is one of the best educations for how and why mobs are formed that this reviewer has seen (and, mind you, this is a pretty saturated genre). “Fargo” postulates that mobs are disenfranchised groups shut out of the mainstream economy who must combine a hierarchy with muscle to claim their space among rival disenfranchised herds. The more you know, kids! In its fourth season, the series is an anthology that’s spiritually tied to the Coens 1996 film and nothing is more Coenesque than rich, eccentric characters. On both sides of the Fatta/Cannon feud, there was an ample amount of iconic larger-than-life figures (congrats Chris Rock on finding a role) and eccentric scatterbrains to make Joel and Ethan would be proud. 

11. Star Trek: Lower Decks (CBS All-Access)-Until this year, Star Trek had aired a combined 732 episodes and (as far as I know) only two have ever focused exclusively on the lower ranks of the ship. While TNG’s “Lower Decks” and Voyager’s “The Good Shephard” were a start, there are still so many holes in Star Trek's supposed post-capitalist society:  Wouldn’t there be any slackers or rebels? Fortunately, Beckett Mariner (Tawny Newsome) has traits of both. This is a show that is deeply in tune with the subject that it’s parodying. If you’ve ever wanted the “Next Generation” characters to loosen up beyond a boring jazz trombone open mic or a poker game that no one mysteriously goes all in on (both tropes that “Lower Decks” lampshades with glee), this is the show for you.  

12. Bless the Harts (Fox)- The endearing portrait of small-town Carolina life is rarely condescending and when it is, it comes from the perspective of a native daughter (“Up All Night” show runner Emily Spivey) poking fun at her own friends. Each of the four main characters is extremely endearing and there’s been a lot of world building towards some of the lesser characters (including the high-pitched Randy and the cheery news lady whose mouth is glued into a smile ala the Jack Nicholson Batman film). The show centers around a lower class North Carolina family and a waitress with modest aspirations to rise above her station; her sly mother (whose primary motivations in life are besting her rival Crystal Lynn, feeling young enough that she can flirt with construction workers, and pulling off semi-fraudulent schemes), her boyfriend (a trucker persona who’s openly a teddy bear underneath), and her dead-panning daughter.

Ten Runners-Up (very close call):

Cobra Kai (YouTube/Netflix), Middleditch and Schwartz (Netflix), Miracle Workers: Dark Ages (TBS), Never Have I Ever (Netflix), Nora from Queens (Comedy Central), Solar Opposites (Hulu), Space Force (Netflix), Teenage Bounty Hunters (Netflix), Unorthodox (Netflix), We Are the Champions (Netflix)

 

Everything else I watched:

American Dad (TBS)*, Archer (FX), Animaniacs (Hulu), Black Monday (Showtime), BoJack Horseman (Netflix), Broke (CBS), Carnival Row (Amazon), Comedy IQ (BYU TV), Connected (Netflix)*. Crossing Swords (Hulu), Everything’s Gonna be OK (Freeform), Explained (Netflix), Five Apartments (Peacock), Fresh off the Boat (ABC), Duncanville (Fox)*, Good Girls (NBC), Good Place (NBC), Joe Pera Talks to You (Adult Swim), Holey Moley (ABC), Hollywood (Netflix), Hoops (Netflix), Intelligence (Peacock), Kidding (Showtime), Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO), Loafy (Comedy Central), Medical Police (Netflix), New Pope (HBO)*, Ozark (Netflix)*, Pen15 (Hulu), Politician (Netflix), Queen’s Gambit (Netflix), Quiz (AMC) , Saved by the Bell (Peacock), Sex Education (Netflix), Schooled (ABC), Schitt’s Creek (Pop TV), Simpsons (Fox)*, Solar Opposites (Hulu), Some Good News (Youtube), Space Force (Netflix), Stumptown (ABC), Studio C (BYU TV), Tales from the Loop (Amazon), A Teacher (FX), Tiger King* (Netflix), Transplant (NBC), Twilight Zone (CBS All Access), Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt (Netflix), Umbrella Academy (Netflix), Unorthodox (Netfflix), Upload (Amazon), Utopia (Amazon), Waco (Netflix), Where’s Waldo (Peacock), White Lines (Netflix), Zoey’s Infinite Playlist (NBC)

*=Very limited capacity

Reviews: Ramy Season 2, Brockmire Season 2, Intelligence, Broke, Once Upon a Time Season 7, Where's Waldo (Peacock)

Ramy (Hulu)-One of the best shows of the year for sure. Review here: 

https://www.tvfanatic.com/2020/07/ramy-season-2-boasts-a-uniquely-introspective-character-despite/

Brockmire (IFC) -A lot of TV in the #metoo era is about men getting consumed by dark pasts. No one seemed more hopeless than the superhumanly aloof baseball broadcaster Jim Brockmire in the first season, but his redemptive arc that gelled in the final season makes such a light out of the tunnel not only seem possible but easy-peasy. 

The leap over a decade into our future is ambitious to say the least (especially for a show based on a Funny or Die sketch) and that's not counting all the emotional overtones. The show is now set at a time where global warming, automation, and split national interests have spiraled out of control and baseball is just one of the show’s casualties.

If you fell off this show due to any perceived dip in quality, that’s not a problem here.

Final Season Aired in 2020, Streaming on Hulu.

Intelligence (NBC Peacock)-The strokes are a little broad here but it’s essentially the egotistical elitist gets humbled by the peons office comedy formula. The gimmick of the show is that it takes place in the English CIA and the fish out of water is an American so it has a little bit of a satirical bent towards American arrogance from a Eurocentric lens.

If I’m complaining about the lack of originality it’s because Space Force just did this but, hey, it’s a good time as any to puncture the myth of American exceptionalism.

As a show, it’s mildly funny if a bit obvious. Whereas Space Force or similar shows about jerks in power (Newsradio, The Office) might have allowed some wiggle room for us not to hate the guy who’s taking up the majority of the screen time: Either he learned or got his comeuppance. In the three episodes I’ve seen, the consequences of this awful man’s actions are mostly sidestepped. Perhaps, it’s a British comedic sensibility to go darker?

The side characters have potential and if the Office improved, it’s possible that this one could go that route too.

Broke (CBS)-Natasha Leggero and her suave Latino husband Javier (Jamie Camil) are rich and out-of-touch people who lose all their money in a pyramid (not a scheme, mind you, but they buy a pyramid [cue laughter]). They have to move in with their lower-class sister (Pauley Perrette) and, like the dad-son combo in Frasier, there’s a class difference so enormous, it’s hard to believe the two are related and grew up in the same house. On the other hand, hey, they wouldn’t have a show if they seriously addressed this, so shhh.

This show has a laugh track which doesn’t disqualify it by being good for modern standards but puts it at a disadvantage. Watching this was an interesting exercise for me in studying just how much the laugh track has devolved; how weaker jokes might get into the script for the purpose of an immediate pay-off.

Still, as far as outdated laugh-track shows go, this one’s watchable. Javier’s wealth-based aloofness makes him a good scene-stealer and it helps that he has heart. His butler Luis (Izzy Diaz) is even funnier though he’s not used for as many punch lines.

 

On the whole, it’s comfort food.

Once Upon a Time, Season 7 (ABC)-There’s something that just clicks with this show. In the first couple seasons (and probably the ones after, I didn’t watch), the episodes alternate between two universes that are connected. There’s a small town in Maine with a corrupt mayor (Lana Pirella) and police sheriff (Jennifer Morrison) fighting over the soul of the town and influence over a young boy. The second is set in fairy tale land where a hodgepodge of fairy tale stories-Little Red Riding Hood, Rumplestilskin, Snow White, Alice in Wonderland, even Aladdin and Princess and the Frog-interact in some variation on the land of Mother Grimm (based in the forests of Germany).

What makes the show work is that these traditional fairy tales are given a twist and then re-interpreted through a modern universe where, say, Snow White is a school teacher who hooks up with Jiminy Cricket, and Rumplestilskin doesn’t just want a first-born but control of the whole town.

Like most serialized TV, however, six seasons is a lot to keep up with multiple levels of mythology to sort through. Fortunately, season seven gives a fresh restart. Henry Mills (the little boy who knows about the alternate universe) is grown-up and is now not just an adult but also a skeptic. And the evil mayor is now just a bartender and one of the good guys in true American Horror Story fashion. As someone who missed some of the in-between seasons, a background detail here and there gets confusing, but for the most part, it’s a self-contained story that balances episodic and serialized elements well.

 

Streaming on Netflix

 

I’m Dying Up Here, Season 2 (Showtime)-Relatively watchable serialized comedy set in the 70s that focuses on the arts. Ari Gaynor (a poor man's Kate Hudson) stars with Oscar winner Melissa Leo and Michael Angarono (Will and Grace, The Knick), Clark Duke and Jake Lacy co-starring. Duke and Lacy were the two last-season additions to The Office as entry-level twerps and they've both been carving out impressive careers for themselves. There's also a couple token black guys with Erik Griffin making the bigger impression of the two. The characters sort of blend into another and there's a lot of cocaine and sex in a premium cable sort of way. The series is meant as a time capsule of the 70s but I'd rather re-watch Baz Luhrmann's Get Down or watch some more Glow. In other words, it's not that insular of a genre. The biggest mistake of the series is that Melissa Leo's character doesn't get more screen time.

Where's Waldo (Peacock)-I could totally see a faithful adaptation of Where's Waldo working. Waldo likes to hide and he's in exotic places so that's something to run with. Instead the series is a weak knock-off of Carmen Sandiego and Wizard Whitebeard is too cartoonish to feel like the adult of the group.