I recently had the pleasure of being invited to contribute to Cory Barker's blog TV Surveillance in his latest 2013 wrap-up roundtable.
I was intrigued with another open question he asked of his fellow film critics and wanted to respond on my own:
There
has been a lot of discussion this season about the glut of good TV. Alan
Sepinwall wrote a piece voicing his
frustration on the matter back in April, and I wrote something similar last summer.
Although this is one of the biggest first world problems of all-time, it can be
exhausting trying to keep up with all the “important” shows, the new shows, and
the shows you just enjoy, no matter the quality. This is the first television
season since I started watching “seriously” where I simply couldn’t keep up
with all my desired interests. Some of that has to do with my schedule, but a
lot of it has to do with A.) The increase in the number of interesting projects
and B.) The decline in quality in many shows I probably would have kept with
anyway had I found myself with more time. Therefore, there are really two
things going on here. Did you folks feel this same kind of weight pushing down
on you, and/or were there shows that declined so dramatically that you reached
a point of no return?
Answer:
Unless you're a professional TV writer, TV is a
way to supplement your life and naturally it will be balanced with other time
demands of your life. You can adjust
your answer accordingly if you fall under the category of aspiring
professional, semi-professional or serious hobbyist, but unless you're veering
into being irresponsible, we all have to abide by some sort of TV diet.
To compound the problem, we're living in a Golden
Age of TV. As a result, there are going to be a great number of programs more worthy of your attention than programs you have time to watch.
But this isn't a curse. It's a blessing. In contrast to people who say that TV is a
waste of time and bad for your brain (hi mom and dad!) while praising other
forms of art like cinema or live theater, I maintain that the capacity of TV to
enrich you culturally, socially, and intellectually is greater than ever
before. There's no greater evidence of that than the fact that the amount of
enriching programs on the air exceeds our available time to watch them all.
So if you have to give up on some critically
acclaimed program like Mad Men or Dexter to be able to keep up with Justified
or Enlightened, it's still a win-win situation. The only danger you have of
"losing" as a TV watcher is if
you don't use your TV diet to challenge yourself. If you watch a soap opera,
reality TV show, a standard procedural, or a sitcom that doesn't push the
boundaries (i.e. Two and a Half Men, According to Jim), a rerun of something
you've already seen, then you are just using the medium as comfort food
and guilty of eroding your brain like
your parents (if they were anything like mine when I was younger) accused you
of. Of course, the degree to which
something like Grimm, Raising the Bar, Royal Pains, or Southland transcends the
procedural or whether a certain reality TV show has merit, is up to you the
viewer to justify. But that's part of the fun. I've never bought the
argument that Happy Endings has merit beyond the standard sitcom, but I did
enjoy the process of my fellow film critics slowly discovering that Happy
Endings wasn't a typical sitcom (Cougar Town also falls into this category).
It's not just a blessing, but a challenge. Sure, it is really easy to fall back on TV as
comfort food. It takes a little effort for me to explore something new than to
fall back on a rerun of Futurama, Archer or Newsradio which are instant
gratification for me. In fact, since the era of YouTube, my attention span has
significantly shortened to the degree to which an hour-long drama can feel like something of a chore. A
show like Homeland is so suspenseful that I have no trouble jumping on board,
but I've also challenged myself with shows that might not be immediately as
rewarding like Scandal, Revenge, or (the now defunct) Terra Nova to develop myself
intellectually. With a show like Hell on Wheels, it paid off heavily.
As for discarding shows, I've never seen an episode
of Dexter, Friday Night Lights, and have missed large swaths of Mad Men and Breaking
Bad but I don't consider myself the lesser for it as long as whatever I'm watching grows me as a TV watcher. Sure, it might hurt my ambitions
as an aspiring professional TV reviewer, but there's a wealth of material I'm already
exploring.
No comments:
Post a Comment