1.
Ethan
Hawke, First Reformed-What’s most impressive is that there are no overtly
dramatic shouting monologues when you feel the character really has something
to say. You can feel him bottling it up inside.
2.
Rachel
Weisz, Disobedience-The performance is helped along by the absence of a
score in some places. The soundscape (mirroring a horror film to some degree)
matches the performance really well and there’s also the fact that Weisz has to
play discomfort in the first half without revealing too much of a larger truth
(her past attraction to McAdams’ character)
3.
Christian
Bale, Vice-It boils down largely to “It’s Christian Bale, what do you
expect?” There’s a lot of nuance in playing Bale
4.
Rachel
Weisz, The Favourite-The stand-out in this film because she’s so devious
and fun. If Emma Stone donned an accent, it might have been more of a contest
5.
Mahershala
Ali, Green Book-I feel like
accent-wise he Sidney Poitiered it up a wee bit too much and I could sense
inconsistencies accent-wise, so deducting a little for that. Other than that,
it’s a tour-de-force performance worthy of an Oscar. Obviously, it should be a
lead but the marketing team at Universal was smart enough to place him in a
weak field where there’d be no question he could win with all the fluctuations
of a long season
6.
Kiki
Layne, If Beale Street Could Talk-In particular, I remember the indelible
montage of her working long days behind a retail counter while pregnant and
then succumbing to labor
7.
Alessandro
Nivola, Disobedience-“You are free!” So much subtlety in this performance
and so many uncomfortable situations. “Disobedience” and “The Favourite” were
easily the most challenging and successfully acted films of the year
8.
Rachel
McAdams, Disobedience-McAdams’s Oscar nomination came from being elevated by
the prestige of starring in sn eventual Best Picture winner in a week year.
This is miles above that role.
9.
Rami
Malek, Bohemian Rhapsody-I was originally happy to see him win an Oscar but
upon rewatching this film a second time on an airplane, BORRRING. I believe I
was so blind to its flaws on the first watch because I knew nothing about Queen
and they are a really interesting story. Mercury was an ethnic and sexual
outliar to his time while gaining exalted status as a rock God and he was also
intellectually ahead of his time. If you already are aware of Queen the novelty
wears off fast and that applies for the performance too. However, there is a
certain multi-directional charisma Malek bought to the role that helped move it
along. I was planning on ranking him higher but A) He didn’t sing and B) He has
a certain naivette in the first half of the film that sort of leaves more
questions than it answers.
10.
Ben
Foster, Leave No Trace-Proud to brag here that I attended a screening with
Foster appearing afterwards in Q &A. Since the days of “Big Trouble” and
“X-Men: The Last Stand”, I’ve been a fan of this guy. He generally has a look that gets him cast in
baddies or rough-and-tumble guys.
11.
Viola
Davis, Doubt-I’m not as much of a fan lately of Davis for reasons that have
to do with her (publicly disowning “The Help)
and reasons absent (the attention she gets in comparison to costars), but
It was a creative choice to grant her a BAFTA nomination. As the lead, she
plays a key role in elevating a genre film to a work with the kind of
socio-economic that might get the Oscars
talking.
12.
Cynthia
Evro, Bad Times at El Royale-Aside from her wonderful singing voice, she
brings the fear and tension and when she smashes that bottle over the
dude’s head (it would spoil it to
identify the victim of her smash but I left a hint there), it’s a show-stopper
of a scene. This film has a very strong ensemble
13.
Jon Hamm,
Beirut-Squinting at intelligence reports, ruminating over high-pressure
decisions, talking with the authority of a well-versed operative against
various diplomats, this is the kind of stuff they gave Claire Danes Emmys for
in “Homeland” and Hamm deserves at least a sliver of the same attention here
for a fine performance in a film that opened at the wrong time of year. Like
Viola Davis, the movie’s ability to transcend genre rests entirely on him.
14.
Regina
King, If Beale Street Could Talk-An excellent choice for Best Supporting Actress
if they’re not going to go with Weisz. The scene where she pleads to the Puerto
Rican for her son-in-law’s life is that showstopping moment an Oscar campaign
needs for the highlight reel but she’s present in every scene.
15.
Emma
Stone, The Favourite-This film is a collection of great scenes and she had
a number of standout moments I can’t deny. If she put just a bit more work into
an accent or just felt more of the period, I could have felt like she was
carrying more of her weight.
16.
Olivia
Coleman, The Favourite-It’s always nice to see the Oscar prognosticators be
made fools of on Oscar night. After all, the spirit of the event is to be
elated when a name is called on the big night and those prognosticators try to
mathematically shortcut the process and suck the fun out of it. Besides, Olivia
Coleman has been a vibrant up-and-comer who has enhanced everything she’s done
and Glenn Close isn’t owed anything just because she’s been nominated before.
However, the screen time was a bit short to get all worked up about.
17.
Colin
Farrell, Widows-I’m not one of those types who goes around saying “I’m
gonna write a screenplay someday” but I occasionally have imaginary movie ideas
I’m developing in my head and one of them is about an apathetic politician
exactly like the kind Colin Farrell played in this film which is kind of creepy
yet remarkable. One way to measure a good supporting performance is if you want
to see a whole film developed about the side character and in this case, yes.
18.
Tim Blake
Nelson, Ballad of Buster Scruggs-If this singing cowboy had the whole film
to himself, I could say it having some kind of Jack-Sparrow-like potential in
terms of making a dent in pop culture and getting action figures and the like.
19.
Thomasin
McKenzie, Leave No Trace-I remember it being a great movie with a solid
relationship in the center, but I don’t have that sensory memory so many
months later of what this performance
felt like.
20.
Marina
del Taverna, Roma-Is the “d” capitalized or lower-case. Discuss amongst
yourselves (or look it up)
21.
Viggo
Mortensen, Green Book-A bit stereotypically Italian but f the Green Book
critics who are continuing to perpetuate the myth that the movie’s inaccurate.
I’m assuming Mortensen did his homework
22.
Jeff
Bridges, Bad Times at El Royale-After seeing Jeff Bridges in interviews, I
have a sneaking suspicion that this seven-time Oscar nominee has just been
playing variations of his stoned hippie self for a long time. I’ve seen four of
his seven Oscar-nominated performances and have been unimpressed.
23.
Michael
Palin, Death of Stalin-What a national treasure. His indecisive pickiness
is a great contrast to this unique film
24.
Lakieth
Stanfield, Sorry to Bother You-A terrible and obnoxious movie, but credit
where credit is due.
25.
Sandra
Bullock, Ocean’s 8-Yes, I think she’s more charming than the smug George
Clooney here. This is a playfully fun part and she has a slyness I like
Others I was considering:
Nancy Garcia Garcia, Roma; Donald Glover, Solo; Steve Carell, Vice; Jeffrey Tambour,
Death of Stalin; Rufus Sewell, Death of
Stalin, Lewis Pullman, Bad Times at El Royale; John David Washington, BlacKkKlansman; Amanda
Seyfried, First Reformed